Search LBO-Talk Archives

226 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 72 -- rank: 858

Document Size:	4637
Author:	Turbulo at aol.com
Date:	Fri Apr 8 16:58:40 PDT 2005

227 [lbo-talk] lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 37 -- rank: 858

Luke Weiger : Charles, the money paragraph from Brown's essay: ^^^^^ CB: Thanks Luke. Well, you may meet your burden of proof and shifted it to Churchill for a defense rebuttal. I wonder what the Mandan and Indian traditions say on this. Is Churchill claiming witnesses from the res ?

Document Size:	4920
Author:	Charles Brown
Date:	Wed Apr 6 04:39:13 PDT 2005

228 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 37 -- rank: 858

Luke Weiger wrote: >Afterwards, tell me how any sane person could regard Churchill's genocide >claim as anything other than bullshit at best or knowing fabrication at wors >t. Who fucking cares? Doug

Document Size:	4871
Author:	Doug Henwood
Date:	Tue Apr 5 15:18:29 PDT 2005

229 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 37 -- rank: 858

Charles Brown wrote: > The general evidence is enough for Churchill to make a historical > speculation, well within the history norms of speculation that this was > intentional on the part of some U.S. military personnel. T. Brown and > followers do not have evidence to meet their burden of proof and go ...

Document Size:	6962
Author:	Luke Weiger
Date:	Tue Apr 5 14:56:19 PDT 2005

230 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 19 -- rank: 858

Luke Weiger wrote: >It's hardly paradoxical to believe that Churchill shouldn't have been fired >for his odious post-9/11 comments (thankfully, he's no longer in any real >danger on that score) and that the US government did really nasty things to >Native Americans while also believing that ...

Document Size:	7697
Author:	joanna bujes
Date:	Sun Apr 3 20:40:30 PDT 2005

231 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 19 -- rank: 858

> Doug wrote: > >> Oh please. This isn't about "scholarship" - it's deeply political. >> It's about what people are allowed to say in public, and what >> universities are allowed to teach. It's about admitting the murderous >> history of the U.S. instead of factchecking a hothead's footnotes. If ...

Document Size:	7691
Author:	T Fast
Date:	Sun Apr 3 19:54:25 PDT 2005

232 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 8 -- rank: 858

>>Chuck wrote: > >Whatever. This is not evidence of academic misconduct. Until the >recent attacks on Churchill, I had long been under the impression >that the U.S. had conducted germ warfare against the Mandans and >other plains nations. I don't recall getting this information from >Churchill, so it must ...

Document Size:	5159
Author:	Marta Russell
Date:	Sun Apr 3 15:48:23 PDT 2005

233 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 8 -- rank: 858

Thomas Brown wrote: >And why should I keep quiet about Churchill's research misconduct, >just because right-wingers don't like his insults to the 9/11 dead? Has O'Reilly called yet? Doug

Document Size:	4850
Author:	Doug Henwood
Date:	Sun Apr 3 10:31:24 PDT 2005

234 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 8 -- rank: 858

Thomas Brown wrote: > Vague rumors of smallpox blanket genocide predate Churchill, but have > never been substantiated against the US. Churchill appears to be > responsible for fabricating all of the most crucial details of his > Mandan story. If he has a source that gives these details, he didn't > cite it. Meanwhile ...

Document Size:	6879
Author:	Chuck0
Date:	Sat Apr 2 17:21:10 PST 2005

235 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 8 -- rank: 858

On Apr 2, 2005, at 3:43 PM, Thomas Brown wrote: > Which of Wiener's examples is worse than faking a genocide? And why > should I keep quiet about Churchill's research misconduct, just > because right-wingers don't like his insults to the 9/11 dead? > I don't see ...

Document Size:	5265
Author:	martin
Date:	Sat Apr 2 16:24:33 PST 2005

236 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 16, Issue 8 -- rank: 858

Michael Perelman wrote: > >He fabricated it? No one had made the claim before? Vague rumors of smallpox blanket genocide predate Churchill, but have never been substantiated against the US. Churchill appears to be responsible for fabricating all of the most crucial details of his Mandan story. If he has a source ...

Document Size:	5855
Author:	Thomas Brown
Date:	Sat Apr 2 15:43:04 PST 2005

237 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 9, Issue 283 -- rank: 858

----- Original Message ----- From: <MRDelucia at aol.com> >>I knew a guy in grad school who said of dissertations, if >>you take more than 200 pages, you haven't mastered your >>material. Similar point. >Can this be applied to Hegel too? LOL >Brian Dauth Hegel's writing style may be dense ...

Document Size:	5677
Author:	Eubulides
Date:	Fri Sep 24 15:36:14 PDT 2004

238 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 9, Issue 283 -- rank: 858

>>I knew a guy in grad school who said of dissertations, if >>you take more than 200 pages, you haven't mastered your >>material. Similar point. >Can this be applied to Hegel too? LOL >Brian Dauth Hegel's writing style may be dense but his ideas aren't sooo complicated ...

Document Size:	5151
Author:	MRDelucia at aol.com
Date:	Fri Sep 24 15:18:24 PDT 2004

239 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 9, Issue 56 -- rank: 858

An ad hominem attack by association (Columbia) and no substantive reply to legitimate points raised. So impressive. >Message: 5 >Date: Sun, 5 Sep 2004 18:53:05 -0400 (GMT-04:00) >From: John Lacny <jlacny at earthlink.net> >Subject: Re: [lbo-talk] STOP CHEAP ATTACKS ON NADER >To: lbo-talk at ...

Document Size:	5855
Author:	Fed. of Fortune 500 Killers
Date:	Sun Sep 5 19:40:52 PDT 2004

240 [lbo-talk] Re: lbo-talk Digest, Vol 9, Issue 51 -- rank: 858

thesis of the book sounds fine, but hope it is only the reviewers exclusion that merely mentions the idiocy of the jesus myth and the middle east threat posed by christian fundamentalists, and leaves out the nuclear weapons jewish maniacs and the equally idiotic crap about moses having lunch with god ...

Document Size:	4976
Author:	Frank Scott
Date:	Sun Sep 5 16:45:41 PDT 2004