Search LBO-Talk Archives

886 Justin Schwartz" <jkschw at hotmail.com> -- rank: 312

Justin Schwartz" <jkschw at hotmail.com> Subject: Re: marxist sociology > >Justin: Matterof fact, I bet you 99 out of 100 >Marxist philosopher could do no better. > >^^^^^^^ Charles (below) says that Marxist philosophers would know about Kant. But that's not what I said they wouldn't know; I said they would ...

Document Size:	8608
Author:	Charles Brown
Date:	Wed Feb 20 13:46:31 PST 2002

887 [lbo-talk] Principled Discoursin' : BDL on Sweezy) -- rank: 312

... s original statement commits tu quoque fallacy with respect to Stalin , as Michael Perelman alluded to. Being a mass murderer is irrelevant to the validity of Stalin's opinion on the continued operation of the law of ... because he accuses Sweezy of bad motive in agreeing with Stalin. Not that Sweezy has made a bad argument, but that ...

Document Size:	5824
Author:	Charles Brown
Date:	Mon Mar 1 14:01:18 PST 2004

888 [lbo-talk] Call of Duty's Battle of Stalingrad video game -- rank: 312

... own 4-part series "War of the Century: Hitler vs. Stalin" that is dedicated solely to the Eastern Front & which has ... Warlords" 2 x DVD set's 1st episode, "Hitler vs. Stalin," goes into much detail about the Nazi-Soviet Non-Aggression ... flatter either side very much. The British "Warlords: Hitler versus Stalin" episode is on YouTube

Document Size:	6061
Author:	B.
Date:	Sun Jan 4 11:39:29 PST 2009

889 Robeson and the USSR -- rank: 312

I was here in Russia during the whole controversy over bringing back the Soviet Anthem. That was when I lost whatever dregs of respect I still had left for the liberal Russian intelligentsia. You don't nreath a word while millions of your fellow citizens drop into poverty, and then what ...

Document Size:	6373
Author:	Chris Doss
Date:	Mon Feb 11 03:19:57 PST 2002

890 [lbo-talk] Haiti Coup and Left KneeJerks -- rank: 312

... do with the real world? BDL's and MP's Stalin fixations, for instance, have as far as I can tell nothing whatsoever to do with anything Stalin actually did, but are instead crude clubs used to beat ... clever and worldly-wise!" I'm still wondering why supporting Stalin is worse than supporting Yeltsin, which I believe Brad is

Document Size:	5841
Author:	" Chris Doss "
Date:	Tue Mar 2 01:01:19 PST 2004

891 [lbo-talk] Stalinism (was Eric Hobsbawm) -- rank: 312

... aka socialism in a single country) is the proclamation by Stalin, at the start of the extermination of the bolsheviks, that ...

Document Size:	8993
Author:	andie_nachgeborenen
Date:	Fri Oct 12 09:45:36 PDT 2012

892 [lbo-talk] I Hate Daniel Goldhagen. (Was Re: Reading suggestions needed -- rank: 312

Weell, I didn't mean to imply that Stalin had a general Judeaocide planned, sorry if I seemed to ... I just read Zhores Medvedev's book on this. > Actually Stalin never engaged in mass killing of > anybody on ethnic grounds. > > Stalin did scatter the Volga Germans through alien > lands

Document Size:	8338
Author:	andie nachgeborenen
Date:	Fri Apr 25 11:36:20 PDT 2008

893 [lbo-talk] Stalinism (was Eric Hobsbawm) -- rank: 312

... aka socialism in a single country) is the proclamation by Stalin, at the start of the extermination of the bolsheviks, that ...

Document Size:	8632
Author:	Shane Mage
Date:	Thu Oct 11 13:23:05 PDT 2012

894 [lbo-talk] Haiti Coup and Left KneeJerks -- rank: 312

... spit my little peashooter criticism! !{)> >BDL's and MP's Stalin fixations, for instance, have as far as I can tell >nothing whatsoever to do with >anything Stalin actually did, but are >

Document Size:	7560
Author:	Todd Archer
Date:	Tue Mar 2 05:25:09 PST 2004

895 Minus 50 in winter, but Russia's Jews love it -- rank: 312

... in Russia's far east December 20, 2002 AFP Joseph Stalin deported them by the thousands to Russia's Far East ... Jews who live in the Jewish autonomous region created by Stalin near the Chinese border in 1934. The republic's Jewish ...

Document Size:	8175
Author:	ChrisD(RJ)
Date:	Tue Dec 24 06:44:12 PST 2002

896 war and the state -- rank: 312

... same vein, it does not make much sense to blame Stalin for all evils > that happened in the Soviet state. For ... aol.com: > Good point, Wojtek. But, he doesn't blame Stalin. He blames Lenin and > Trotsky! To _blame_ Lenin and Trotsky ...

Document Size:	5743
Author:	Gordon Fitch
Date:	Fri Aug 30 04:58:02 PDT 2002

897 war and the state -- rank: 312

At 01:33 PM 8/29/2002 -0400, Gordon wrote: >"Bullshit" isn't much of an argument. Witte was a Stalinist >of some sort _avant_la_lettre_? As for protectionism and Calling someone a "stalinist" is not much of an argument either. I think your argument suffers from a problem of ...

Document Size:	7066
Author:	Wojtek Sokolowski
Date:	Thu Aug 29 11:40:30 PDT 2002

898 Raimondo does Hitchens -- rank: 312

... has a quart of milk." RangerCat67: >The implication being that Stalin had good intentions? Raimondo goes on: "The spectacle, in all ... its peculiarity, rolls on. Hitchens has his own softness for Stalin & Co., as chronicled in a new book by Martin Amis ...

Document Size:	7410
Author:	Peter K.
Date:	Mon Aug 26 17:41:15 PDT 2002

899 Raimondo does Hitchens -- rank: 312

RangerCat67 at aol.com wrote: >The implication being that Stalin had good intentions? As Hitch once said, in response to the standard Stalin = Hitler equivalence, "At least with Stalin, he was betraying something." Doug

Document Size:	4694
Author:	Doug Henwood
Date:	Mon Aug 26 10:05:30 PDT 2002

900 Principled Discoursin' (was Re: [lbo-talk] BDL on Sweezy) -- rank: 312

Michael Dawson -PSU wrote: >Meanwhile, why the hell are you defending DeLong? http://www.1866funtoread.com/ then, you and Charles can reread what I wrote: "(Note, I agree with Doug and Max, here; so can it if you think I'm defending de Long's commentary on Sweezy. Why I should ...

Document Size:	9756
Author:	kelley at pulpculture.org
Date:	Tue Mar 2 06:31:56 PST 2004